Lukashenko says he may quit as president
Belarus hits EU with tit-for-tat sanctions
Belarusian police introduce colour-coded torture system for detained protesters
Kremlin publicly condemns Belarusian police brutality in hint of growing frustration with Lukashenko
Russian services PMI rises to 48.2, but remains underwater as recovery continues to slow
Russia to start mass vaccinations on December 7
Azerbaijan’s Aliyev calls on Armenia, Russia, Turkey and Iran to assist in creating Nakhchivan land corridor
FPRI BMB Russia: Sberbank releases a three-year transformation strategy to e-commerce concern
Ukraine’s banking sector continues recovery, but profits still lagging last year
Ukraine’s real wages up over 10% in October but have been stagnant in dollar terms for almost a year
FPRI BMB Ukraine: Public has confused opinions on resolving the Donbas conflict
Western Balkans plus Ukraine subsidised coal with over €900mn in 2018-2019
Estonian parcel robot firm Cleveron eyes €30mn state loan
Estonia’s chief auditor says €1bn in state COVID-19 loans issued haphazardly
Economic sentiment in CEE falls in November as recovery momentum splutters
Estonian animation studio Imepilt to hold IPO
Brighter days ahead: The economic bounce back in 2021
Central, Southeast Europe stock markets jump in anticipation of COVID-free future
VISEGRAD BLOG: An easing of trade tensions but still an uncertain situation for export-oriented Central Europe
Hungary's PM risks isolation as Poland mulls dropping EU budget veto
Poland ready to back down from veto of EU budget
Hungary's ruling party in damage control mode after MEP sex scandal bombshell
Poland’s PMI remains stuck just above the improvement line at 50.8 in November
Czech companies dominate this year’s Deloitte Technology Fast 50 CE
Coronacrisis to get worse before it gets better forecasts wiiw
EU diplomats say no chance of Bulgaria removing veto for Skopje to start EU accession talks
IMF says downside risks to Albanian economy are increasing
EU ministers fail to agree on launch of accession talks with Albania and North Macedonia
Western Balkans commit to green agenda and regional common market at Sofia summit
Bosnia’s opposition ousts nationalist parties in major cities
Bosnia’s main ethnic parties fight to hold onto power in local elections
Southeast Europe’s EU members to get biggest boost from next budget and recovery funds
Bulgaria imposes 3-week lockdown to slow down COVID-19 spread
CEE politicians highlight trade and security ties as they congratulate Biden
Breakaway Transnistria fully under Sheriff’s control as Obnovlenie party sweeps board in parliament election
Moldova’s presidential election is over, now the battle for the parliament begins
Moldova’s foreign policy reset
Russian establishment quick to congratulate Moldova's new president-elect
Rising COVID-19 cases put intense pressure on CEE healthcare systems
MEPs urge European Commission to act against Hungarian media financing in North Macedonia and Slovenia
North Macedonia mulls decriminalising cannabis to boost tourism
Retail surpass pre-crisis peak as Romanians shop instead of holiday
Romania’s stability election
Romanian venture capital firm Catalyst launches new €40mn-50mn fund for TMT
The state is back in business
Slovenian PM Jansa stands alongside Hungary and Poland in EU rule of law row
BEYOND THE BOSPORUS: Turkish number crunchers deliver November inflation surprise of 14%
Erdogan needs to go says analyst assessing Turkey’s economic collapse
Ukraine strikes deal with Turkey to produce killer drones instrumental in Karabakh conflict
In Karabakh deal, as many questions as answers
Protesters flood Yerevan demanding Armenia’s “traitor” PM quit over Nagorno-Karabakh surrender
Who emerge as the real winners from the bloody Nagorno-Karabakh conflict?
Below average 2020 wine production destined for volatile and uncertain global market
Iran calls on Saudis to limit $67bn defence spending to Tehran’s $10bn
Iranian prosecutors pledge to pursue Trump for Soleimani killing even after he leaves White House
No reaction from Kazakh elites as bombshell FT report says Nazarbayev’s son in law siphoned millions from pipeline scheme
UK court freezes $5bn in assets connected to fugitive Kazakh banker Ablyazov
Attack of the Debt Tsunami: global debt soars to a new all-time high
Kyrgyzstan's proposed new constitution provokes widespread revulsion
Kyrgyzstan's China debt: Between crowdfunding and austerity
CFC joins RWC in assessing KAZ Minerals buyout offer as under-valuation
China business briefing: Not happy with Kyrgyzstan
Mongolian coal exports to China paralysed as Beijing demands virus testing of truck drivers
Mongolia fears economic damage as country faces up to its first local transmissions of coronavirus
Mongolia in lockdown after suffering first local coronavirus transmissions
Mongolia’s wrestling culture: From the grasslands to the cage
No surprises in Tajikistan as Rahmon retains presidency with 91% of vote
A Tajikistan poised on verge of economic calamity set for vote
Tajikistan revives on-off dispute with Iran
Turkmenistan: The dammed united
Turkmenistan: Everybody yurts, sometimes
Dirty money investigation reviews identified payments worth $1.4bn linked to Turkmenistan
Uzbekistan unveils extensive privatisation programme
Download the pdf version
Though he spent 27 of his 30 years in power leading an independent Kazakhstan as president, Nursultan Nazarbayev first emerged as the country’s leader when in June 1989 he became First Secretary of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of the then Kazakh Soviet Socialist Republic. Prior to that he had spent five years of the Soviet era as prime minister. So his resignation on March 19 is undoubtedly a meaningful milestone for historians: the last of the former Soviet dictators has exited the stage. But let’s not get ahead of ourselves for, certainly in the eyes of many ordinary Kazakhs, the Central Asian nation is still living through a “Soviet-groomed” era and Nazarbayev’s departure does not put an end to that.
Nazarbayev’s plan to continue ruling from behind the scenes aside, there’s a rather muddy picture when it comes to gauging the extent of genuine liberalisation in ex-Soviet states—and that’s especially the case in Central Asia. For every reform-driven Shavkat Mirziyoyev, who is intent on opening up Uzbekistan to foreign investment, there’s a Gurbanguly Berdimuhamedov, who, despite being a modest improvement on his predecessor, has mostly kept remote, tightly controlled Turkmenistan’s Iron Curtain-like policies alive.
Kazakh internet exploded with humour
In Kazakhstan, it’s not just hardened cynics who’ll tell you that 78-year-old Nazarbayev’s handing over of the helm will barely bring about any change. This was clearly apparent in the public reaction to the “Leader of the Nation’s” televised resignation announcement. The Kazakh internet exploded with humour and memes. The move, which essentially sees Nazarbayev loyalist and parliament upper house speaker Kassym-Jomat Tokayev, 65, take over as caretaker president, was dismissed as another facade, a demonstrative act that in reality would mean little to daily life.
There is of course plenty of talk over whether out of sight Nazarbayev is assiduously working on preparing the way to appoint his true successor, very likely using his resignation as an opportunity to place one of his family members in power before he passes away. If the late 2016 death of another ex-Soviet leader, the hard authoritarian Uzbek president Islam Karimov, was sudden and therefore opened up a window for drastic change, Nazarbayev’s carefully choreographed exit only makes sure everything will stay the way he and his camarilla have set in stone. Or so many Kazakhs believe.
The lack of dismay in Kazakh society at Nazarbayev’s ‘abdication’ is not difficult to understand, father of the nation or not. It is safe to say that the Nazarbayev era sometimes felt like little more than an attempt at closely mimicking the times under the country’s former Soviet master, Russia. From building an economy (still seen as a frontier market rather than an emerging market by most indexes) vastly over-reliant on exporting hydrocarbons, to stabilisation funds and the ruble-dependence of the Kazakh tenge, there is a plethora of examples that can be given.
The only real policy divergences took place after the rude reverberations of the 2014 oil price collapse and after the impact of western sanctions hitting Russia and, by extension, its economically interlinked former vassal states. Kazakhstan’s masters suddenly saw that the country needed to focus on diversifying its economy. Though correctly regarded as Central Asia’s economic powerhouse, Kazakhstan is somewhat nervous at the big opening up of neighbouring Uzbekistan to investors. The prospect of Tashkent rather than Astana (or Nursultan as it is now called in honour of Nazarbayev) becoming the region’s economic driver likely does not sit well with Kazakhstan’s elite clans.
Some investor-friendly reforms are now in play. They include attempts at simplifying regulations for subsoil users exploiting mineral reserves, the launch of the Astana International Financial Centre (AIFC) with its promises of tax exemptions and other perks and legal regime based on English common law, and an economic diversification drive with a focus on infrastructure and agriculture. Officials will, meanwhile, not lose sight of potential big investments they might attract under China’s intercontinental Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) for modern-day infrastructure-for-trade.
The Kazakh economy has managed to recover from the downturns it experienced in 2015 and 2016, largely thanks to the oil price recovery. Yet many ordinary Kazakhs have not seen their country’s restored financial health reflected in their quality of life. Nazarbayev’s career highlights as presented by the Kazakh authorities may be paraded before them, but they are typically too abstract to have any meaningful impact on their lives.
Kazakhstan taking a non-permanent membership role at the UN Security Council or hosting a World’s Fair (even if it was in a futuristic building that mimics the Epcot Center in DisneyWorld) are seldom regarded as triumphs. They’re more likely to be dismissed as vanity projects for the out-of-touch ruling class.
Giving credit where credit’s due, let’s remember that Nazarbayev’s Kazakhstan has enjoyed less oppressive conditions than Karimov’s Uzbekistan went through. It’s also considerably freer than Turkmenistan is under Berdimuhamedov (though you might say he’s something of an improvement on predecessor Saparmurat Niyazov).
Where stability is concerned, the Kazakhs have seen nothing even approaching Kyrgyzstan’s two post-Soviet revolutions and political strife and Tajikistan’s civil war in the nineties. Some attribute this relative peace to Kazakhstan’s vast oil reserves; but that wouldn’t explain why gas-rich Turkmenistan and mineral-rich Uzbekistan took paths marred by child and forced labour, the strict regulation of the movement of their peoples both at home and abroad and ugly personality cults surrounding their leaders.
“Radiant Fatherland’s” one-party state
In other areas, however, Kazakhstan has not been too dissimilar to neighbouring ex-Soviet states. Crackdowns on dissent and freedom of speech have been common. The elimination of political opposition in favour of a one-party system has also been widely associated with long-time ruler Nazarbayev (who remains the leader of the ruling Nur Otan, or “Radiant Fatherland”, party as well as the chairman of the national security council).
The major low point of Nazarbayev’s career occurred when striking miners were gunned down in Zhanaozen in 2011—a blemish in Kazakh history that officials still find themselves inconvenienced by.
Since that tragedy, the crackdowns on demonstrators have been markedly less violent. The 2016 anti-land reform protests showed Nazarbayev’s willingness to backtrack on unpopular decisions and recent demands made by Kazakhs across the country for the raising of living standards ended with Nazarbayev ordering the drawdown of $3.6bn from the country’s rainy day fund.
The end of Nazarbayev’s presidency may well have ended the final chapter of Soviet-spawned rule. But as Nazarbayev still holds sway, it can hardly be said to have definitively ended his era. If a handpicked successor is decisively installed during the 2020 presidential election, we might then say such a thing. At that juncture, some analysts suggest, Kazakhstan might move from one-man-rule to something like rule-by-committee or cabal. But there is also the risk that a “Kazakh Putin” will emerge, that a new cult of personality will arise. And the ghostly echoes of the USSR would again be all too present.
here to continue reading this article
and 5 more for free or purchase
12 months full website access including
the bne Magazine for just $250/year.
Register to read the bne monthly magazine for
Password could contain only
and have 8-20 symbols length.
Please complete your registration by confirming your
A confirmation email has been sent to the email
address you provided.
can't be empty.
No user with
this email address.
Access recovery request have been expired. Please,
Access recover request have been expired.
Please, try again.
To continue viewing our content you need to complete
the registration process.
Please look for an email that was sent to
with the subject line
"Confirmation bne IntelliNews access". This email will have
instructions on how to complete registration
process. Please check in your "Junk" folder in
case this communication was misdirected in your
If you have any questions please contact us at firstname.lastname@example.org
Sorry, but you have used all your free articles fro
this month for bne IntelliNews. Subscribe
to continue reading for only $119 per year.
Your subscription includes:
For the meantime we are also offering a free
digital weekly newspaper to subscribers to
the online package.
Click here for more subscription options,
including to the print version of our
flagship monthly magazine:
Take a trial to our premium daily news
service aimed at professional investors that
covers the 30 countries of emerging
For any other enquiries about our
products or corporate discounts please
contact us at
If you no longer wish to receive
Magazine annual print
Website & Archive
Combined package: web
access & magazine print
Take a trial to our premium daily news service
aimed at professional investors that
covers the 30 countries of emerging Europe: